На главнуюОбразованиеПохожее видеоЕще от: Truth Seeker

Richard Dawkins irritated by irrationality

Оценок: 13200 | Просмотров: 1051898
Категория: Образование
Html code for embedding videos on your blog
Текстовые комментарии (4560)
Suzie Park (6 часов назад)
Uhm not quiite
Thor Crowley (6 часов назад)
These religious idiots are just unbearable.A politician that does so boldly declare that he is a fucking brainwashed idiot and that reality is not his thing should not be allowed to decide in matters relating to reality. one should not suffer this level of idiocy and ignorant arrogance without ridicule. I can hardly tolerate that we might even be part of the same species.
Colin Java (7 часов назад)
6:18, the glasses are coming off, that guy is gonna get it bad.
Tom Lohmann (12 часов назад)
Funny since 99.9% of everything Dawkins says is irrational.
Tom Lohmann (10 часов назад)
+Valnain Try a drinking game. Every time Dawkins says something stupid or irrational take a drink. You will get drunk fast. If you want to get drunk even faster try it with Christopher Hitchens. The stupid and irrational comes so fast you can't keep your drink down.
Valnain (11 часов назад)
Wow, religion really does poison everything.
Soviet Union Jack (16 часов назад)
Religion is the sickness ! ... Technological advancement combined with education for ALL ..... Is the cure !
Alex Benton (16 часов назад)
Quotes bible You really didn’t need to ridicule the Bible ...
Serpent Sepia (22 часа назад)
@ 3:15 "The New Testament tells the story of a man who tried to do good things and who began this movement, Christianity, that is still with us today. He must have been an outstanding person, let's face it." I beg to differ.... Mark 7:9-10 Jesus criticizes the Jews for not killing their disobedient children as required by Old Testament law. "And he said unto them, Full well ye reject the commandment of God, that ye may keep your own tradition. For Moses said, Honour thy father and thy mother; and, Whoso curseth father or mother, let him die the death:" Luke 10:10-15 -- Jesus says that entire cities will be violently destroyed and the inhabitants "thrust down to hell" for not "receiving" his disciples. "But into whatsoever city ye enter, and they receive you not, go your ways out into the streets of the same, and say, Even the very dust of your city, which cleaveth on us, we do wipe off against you: notwithstanding be ye sure of this, that the kingdom of God is come nigh unto you. But I say unto you, that it shall be more tolerable in that day for Sodom, than for that city." Matthew 5:17 -- Jesus strongly approves of the law and the prophets. He hasn't the slightest objection to the cruelties of the Old Testament. "Think not that I am come to destroy the law, or the prophets: I did not come to destroy, but to fulfill." Matthew 23:31-35 Jesus condemned people to hell for things that their ancestors supposedly did. "Ye are the children of them which killed the prophets. ... Ye serpents, ye generation of vipers, how can ye escape the damnation of hell? ... Upon you may come all the righteous blood shed upon the earth, from the blood of righteous Abel unto the blood of Zacharias son of Barachias, whom ye slew between the temple and the altar." Mark 16:16 Jesus said that disbelievers will be tormented forever in hell no matter how good they are. "He that believeth and is baptized shall be saved; but he that believeth not shall be damned." Matthew 13:41-42 Jesus plans to torture billions of people forever after they die. "The Son of man shall send forth his angels, and they shall gather out of his kingdom all things that offend, and them which do iniquity; And shall cast them into a furnace of fire: there shall be wailing and gnashing of teeth." Matthew 5:28-30 Jesus believes you should maim and disfigure yourself to save your soul. "Whosoever looketh on a woman to lust after her hath committed adultery with her already in his heart. And if thy right eye offend thee, pluck it out ... And if thy right hand offend thee, cut it off, and cast it from thee: for it is profitable for thee that one of thy members should perish, and not that thy whole body should be cast into hell."
DeGoyen (1 день назад)
Dawkins can not compete with the over studied populism of the politicians
Sharon Balloch (1 день назад)
Pretty sure its irrational to tell his followers that they should allow strangers to put their hands down their sons pants or fondle their daughters.. says it doesn't do any harm..it happened to him and look at him he is normal..never hurt him a bit he says..so go ahead and allow folks to sexually abuse your children.. its the rational thing to do..so says Dawkins.
Jeremiah (1 день назад)
Okay... Santa is god..... he possesses the bodies ever every person, and buys their friends gifts 1 day ever year. Please explain how this idea, is different, than believing in God?
spicecrop (2 дня назад)
Dawkins obviously has no understanding of Holiness.
Valnain (13 часов назад)
No such thing as holiness, dude.
William Nathan (2 дня назад)
Richard makes Aussies dumb
Rick Glasklekter (2 дня назад)
Simply put................I can see why these clowns are in need of a shepard. Go get em jesus.
greyztone (2 дня назад)
To be fair Dawkins is straight up lying at one point here (assuming the editing of this video hasn't distorted things). He says he simply stated what the Christian message/story was without making judgement. He actually stated it and finished by forcefully saying "what kind of a horrible depraved notion is that?" I happen to agree with his judgement, but why be so disingenuous? You either think that using such language in that forum is the correct thing to do or you don't. Don't use it and then deny it. Stand by it and give your justification.
Emily O'Hara (2 дня назад)
Why shouldn't religion be open to ridicule? The man on the panel claiming this of Dawkins must have a very frail faith if it can't handle a little scrutiny. We are grown ups; just because you don't like the messenger doesn't mean you disregard the message.
Giona Cantarutti (2 дня назад)
His point about the sacrifice not being admirable is right but poorly exposed, thus the unfavorable reaction from the crowd. The idea is that if you're omnipotent why let people commit sins in the first place and after that why do you need to suffer to atone them, you can literally snap your fingers and solve the problem. A sacrifice for an omnipotent being is simply free unecessary suffering that is more akin to vengence (as it's supposed to balance out people's sins) than it is to heroism.
Maw 3615054 (2 дня назад)
"I want a morality that is discussed, thought out, etc" Mr Dawkins,, In Africa there are cannibal tribes that would beg to differ your views, perhaps it would be more MORALLY constructive to give us an example of a genetic mutation that resulted in an INCREASE of information within the genome that would support the theory of evolution rather than putting "PEOPLE DOWN" & trying to publicly embarrass them as a strategy for recruiting people to evolutionary BELIEFS!
Valnain (13 часов назад)
You're still clinging to that decades-old creationist canard? That's embarrassing, man.
George Doyle (2 дня назад)
Wow!! I was just thinking, what a stark contrast between the physicist professor Brian Cox and Richard Dawkins emotional IQ and their approach to teaching, promoting and sharing science. Coming from a science background myself i didnt find this debate funny at all and was uncomfortable with the way Dawkins uses science to promote his own personal agenda and books. Brian Cox and Dawkins both explore science, religious belief and atheism in completey different ways. When Professor Brian cox was interviewed about his "atheism" he refused to be labelled as an atheist and stated that he disliked the term because he thought it was devisive. He also stated that science shouldn't really have anything to say about god because we just dont know. A very Interesting and dignified approach from our renowned physicist Brian Cox, in stark contrast to this uncomfortable debate with Dawkins. When scientists like Dawkins start dictating to philosophers and theologians what they should teach and think it comes across as unscientific, very religious and dogmatic as scientists have limited expertise in these more qualitative, valid and valuable areas of study. Aristotle always viewed philosophy and ethics as more important than the sciences when teaching his pupils. I think most of us would agree that any other approach would be madness. I think people are responding negatively to Dawkins teaching style because he seems to claim that science is infallible and above ethics as weve proven humans are just an object formed by chance from a chemical soup. A very nihilistic and unhelpful way to teach science, ground ethics and promote a type of critical thinking that creates unity and improves the human condition. I think most of us would agree theres something more to humans that you can't quite quantify with maths or science because quantative research is the wrong tool for measuring human experiances such as the numinous, love, real altruism etc. Being a qualfied nurse i know that when it comes to caring for people in the "real world" an holistic and qualitative approach is invaluable and that an high emotional IQ, for want of a better expression, can actually save lives. I think Dawkins gets ahead of himself when utilising the valuable tool we call objective science and quantitative research. I think we need to take a more qualitative approach when it comes to measuring the value and validity of culture, historical texts, religion, faith, religious ritual and symbolism etc. Are they not our ancesters real experiances and a valid attempt to imagine the indescribable mysteries and goodness that exists in life. After all in a time when there was no free education it was all they had to promote change, make sense of the world promoting human rights and democracy etc. Dawkins needs to revisit his history lessons (Martin Luther and Democracy etc). I think we need to acknowledge and teach the universal truths and morals contained in every cultures ancient religious texts, myths/fables in order to promote diversity, respsct, learning and positive regard. After all it was Einstein who said that the greatest part of the human intellect was our imagination. "More truth in Myth than fact" etc. And that imagination can help us to find the right direction to follow as humans . I think its arrogant to call people with religious faith poorly educated. In my experience as a qualified nurse there are lots of people in medicine who rely on their faith to get through a shift caring for peoples family better and saving lives .Maybe the problem is that Dawkins lacks imagination and so sadly he comes across as arrogant and dogmatic turning people away from science. There is more than one way to obtain value, measure and get joy, truth and neaning out of life. I think there is also an element of language/liguistics and personal choice including meaning and purpose to consider. "You say tomato i say tomayto". Dawkins says herd instinct and survival value which appears valid when measured within a certain paradigm. Thankfully most of us say and experiance altruism and love. Music the arts, poetry, love and philosophy are all pointless beacuse they have no survival value, rather they are what brings value to survival.
Abzorbo (2 дня назад)
Religion should be ridiculed because it is ridiculous !
Alex Tomlins (3 дня назад)
I wish facts led all education. The fact any adult can believe this horse shit is beyond me. The world needs more Dorkins and less God botherers.
blanca roca (3 дня назад)
the only counter against dawkins was not against his logic but simply against the way he presented his logic. But if Dawkins wasn't such a strident advocate he wouldn't be famous and appearing on TV anyway.
Jimits123 (3 дня назад)
Don’t cast your pearls before swine...can’t wait to see Dawkins on judgment day
Jimits123 (11 часов назад)
Valnain clown
Valnain (13 часов назад)
There's no such thing as a "judgment day," sorry to burst your sadistic vindictive bubble.
Sean Romero (3 дня назад)
Religion is humanity's first and worst attempt at explaining the world around us.
Stan Ky (3 дня назад)
"Richard Dawkins irritated by irrationality" No wonder he's such an angry little troll then, he's as irrational as they come. 0+0+ everything? And this guy is deemed 'smart'?!
Valnain (13 часов назад)
He doesn't have an imaginary friend, so he's got that one on you.
Rich djclarkee (3 дня назад)
Dawkins is a savage
Romen Tsaturyan (3 дня назад)
VENI, VIDI, got slightly irritated, VICI.
trexguy (4 дня назад)
Thank you Mr Dawkins!
MrAlsfan5 (4 дня назад)
Richards Dawkins is right and these other peoples' beliefs are sad and ridiculous.
Matheus Cardoso (4 дня назад)
love seeing christians feeling ridicule by science 😍
Mox Mix (4 дня назад)
Stupid religious monkeys.
Aris (4 дня назад)
5:16 he couldn't handle it
HeWentThattaway (4 дня назад)
Why do I find myself getting angrier with all of these Christians and their self-righteous pompousness the more I watch these videos? The question containing the statement that an atheist can't have morality really got my goat.
Russel Walker (5 дней назад)
Sis what a coward that cant stand up for his own deluded beliefs. Disgusting. Richard Dawkins too is a coward that can't admit his own disrespect and intolerance to religious belief. He should just state it outright like christopher hitchens instead of asking "how was it disrespectful" like kid in a corner.
Sine Porfa (5 дней назад)
Dawkins was a MONSTER in this one. A fucking BOSS.
Helen Heinz (5 дней назад)
I really have no clue why whether someone believes the earth is older or younger than 10,000 yrs old is actually vital. We have many issues and that is not one of them.
Quantum Troll (4 дня назад)
Well if there are people who believe that the earth is younger then 10,000 years old, then we obviously have an issue in the education system. Woudnt you agree ?
Carlinn27 (5 дней назад)
I would leave... I don't know how he can handle being in a room FILLED with morons
Troy Johnson (5 дней назад)
love Dawkins!
Chris Galitz (5 дней назад)
It would be so awesome if He just said all of you that believe in this nonsense are bat shit crazy. Lol
D.C. Gold. (6 дней назад)
2:26 You mean exactly what Christian Missionaries do on a Daily Basis?!?! The F'ing hypocrisy... Christians Say "This is what happened and you have to belive it" Atheists Say "Thats bullshit, heres what we know through scientific discoveries & heres what weve yet to fully discover."
Vance L. Gilmore (6 дней назад)
It is so refreshing being in the company of sane people who think clearly and are rational. Also, I believe that both creation and evolution are correct. We were created, and then continue to evolve into more perfect versions of people.
viktor1496 (4 дня назад)
+Vance L. Gilmore -Runs away after i bring up that we already long know how earth was created -Calls it a difference of opinion and implies that i'm somehow not capable of having a nice day Man....you must be a JOY to be around
Vance L. Gilmore (5 дней назад)
+viktor1496 - whatever, fella. I do not wish to argue or converse with you at all any longer on this topic as it seems we have irreconcilable differences of opinion. Have a nice day, if you can. Goodbye.
viktor1496 (5 дней назад)
+Vance L. Gilmore Well i just quote you bud "I logically conclude that the planet itself and everything on it must also have been created by something or someone" If you mean the forces of nature with that...sure. But Life and our planet were not specially created. If you want to argue that god however just made the big bang happen and then just left it alone.....be my guest, nothing i can say to refute that hahaha
Vance L. Gilmore (5 дней назад)
+viktor1496 - perhaps that is so. It really does not concern me very much because I exist here now, not back then. Also, we can observe how we ourselves can create things that operate on their own once we have put them together. If we can do that, then it is logical to conclude that something else may also be able to do that on much larger scales. I am also aware that humans are not the highest form of intelligent life.
viktor1496 (5 дней назад)
+Vance L. Gilmore You might be interested in knowing that how our planet was formed is hardly a mystery. The earth and the rest of the solar system was gradually formed in the accretion disc that formed our sun....we see this happening everywhere in the universe. The only thing needed for our planet was the "natural resource" which was a nebula, gravity and electromagnetic interactions bud ;) nature doesn't need someone guiding it
Ricahrd P'Brien (6 дней назад)
This is sort of funny.
Bushwhacker (6 дней назад)
God is not dead. He never exsisted in the first place.
アントニーAnthony (6 дней назад)
I love this guy lol
Marrycat7218 (6 дней назад)
Steve Fielding, typical politician doing his job, that is avoiding the answer.
Purger 1 (6 дней назад)
Richard Dawkins rules!👍
Mason Willis (7 дней назад)
The atheists definitely all sat together, you can tell when they clap lol
Nas 1758 (7 дней назад)
Could you imagine if that man was a Muslim or a Jew? and they brought him out like that on TV and had a crowd applaud him being belittled?
Ricahrd P'Brien (6 дней назад)
+Nas 1758 You can find videos right on this site where that happens. Look them up. Here is one where Richard Dawkins is mocking a Muslim about his beliefs that Muhammed split the Moon, rode on a winged horse, etc. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nQ-Y5NWV9kc
Nas 1758 (6 дней назад)
+Ricahrd P'Brien And what do you think would happen?
Ricahrd P'Brien (6 дней назад)
Yes.
Gary Miller (7 дней назад)
Dawkins if that what you believe you have never read the Bible man i wish i could sit down with a fool like this and rip him one
Gary Miller (7 дней назад)
Jesus is NOT GOD
viktor1496 (3 дня назад)
+Leonard Miller I'll put out a famous quote from Mark Twain who greatly helped form the field of geology "If the Eiffel tower were now representing the world's age, the skin of paint on the pinnacle-knob at its summit would represent man's share of that age; and anybody would perceive that that skin was what the tower was built for. I reckon they would, I dunno." Why don't you think about that for a while?
viktor1496 (3 дня назад)
+Leonard Miller "יוֹם" or yom in the grammatical context it is used in in Genesis can only specify day. It can be used as a period of time in other context don't google translate it please Also: doctors are far, FAR from scientists. They practice a craft and learn a decent amount of biology and chemistry but that's about it. Show me a physicist, geologist, Astronomer.... that believes young earth creationism and i'll give you points. But alas, those people do not exist
Leonard Miller (3 дня назад)
+viktor1496 he ones i know of don't believe in creationism either and for that matter niether do i because the world and universe were never created in 7 literal days my friend, 7 periods of time yes and these are undetermined in length but know doubt Jehovah being an orderly God they would be of a similar length. And also these are scientists from every walks of science i also happen to many practicing doctors that see intelligent design in what they do, and know they cannot deny what they see so believe in a practical sense the same as me i proved the Bible to be true and the word of God
Leonard Miller (3 дня назад)
+viktor1496 the Hebrew word we translate 'day' transliterates as an unspecified period of time we use the owrd day because our small minds have no other concept of time we have to eastablish a parameter and there is nothing wrong with that provided in Bible study classes the truth is taught. Anybody that holds the so called 'ho;y trinity' to be true is involved in a form of pagan worship yes and many things the catho;ic church does are pagan bought into the church to attract ones of pagan faiths, and the trut of the matter is we must put on the personality of Christ not change the Bible or make up belief systems to appease different groups of people. e.g i had a Baptist lay preacher as someone i visited because i think we both enjoyed the company and intelligent conversation and trying to convince each other about certain beliefs in our faiths. John his actual name the poor guy has passed many yers ago now asked me a very important question in my mind anyway and iy has never left me' He said "Gary how do you keep your people in line without the threat of hell fire" my answer we teach then to love and not to dissapoint the one they love. I also asked him about what he thought of hell fire and he knew it was a pagan teaching then the next question he asked me on the same day was "Gary how many parishioners have a Bible at our meetings" my answer 100% his answer when i asked him maybe 3 Bibles in the whole congregation and he said that would be on a good day.. Make up your own mind but those conversations are true.
viktor1496 (4 дня назад)
+Gary Miller There are many who believe in god though, and that's totally ok as long as it doesn't contradict the evidence we have. people who believe in guided evolution for example, or that god was the author of the big bang. Also: are you refuting that "יוֹם" is the original word used int he hebrew texts? Because that's the word for day, it can't be translated any other way. So yes it says days And The holy trinity is a core concept of catholicism, ar you calling all catholics pagans?
Gary Miller (7 дней назад)
Richard Dawkins is the irrational one he is the most spew worthy so called scientist. The Bible dosen't say the world was made in 7 individual days it is 7 periods of time and how long were those periods of time ask Jehovah God
TheFractured Show (3 дня назад)
Gary Miller I tried he didn’t answer. Maybe he was talking to Satan, since they are just so bad.
Český Hráč (7 дней назад)
stroke incomiiing!!!
rakat sceptic (7 дней назад)
Reported for RAPE and NUDITY
Brett Manning (7 дней назад)
Dawkins is an inconsistent idiot. He pretends to have an ethic without any foundation. Without God and his perfect word, it’s impossible to have an ethic. All knowledge is fallacious unless you have 100% truth. One percent of available knowledge is radically altered by the 99% that each individual does not possess. The problem with the gentleman next to Richard Dawkins is he doesn’t take a strong opinion. I would tell him that the earth is absolutely young. And that evidence points to it, God‘s word points to it and that it is an actual impossibility for the earth to be that old, just starting from the decrease in magnetic force on the earth. The earth is older than 10,000 years, the magnetic energy should pull all the iron out of the blood. The complexity of the sellers irreducibly complex. It had to be created at once or not at all. He marks people of faith but one day he himself will be marked. And people laugh with incredulity like laughter is an argument. He doesn’t actually produce any arguments except Arrogant disbelief and dismissiveness.
Bee Snort (8 дней назад)
He’s my hero!
H Brughuis (8 дней назад)
Religious people are indeed dumb as a sack of beans... All of them...without exception.... It's a powerful tool for politicians and their masters to defuse the people...and it's working...look at this nobrains at the left who gets aggressive against Dawkins...
jaidee76 (8 дней назад)
Tony Burke represents what is wrong in society today. He is the disrespectful one!! Shame on him.
Martin Carter (8 дней назад)
Dawkins always gets a laugh, and is always able to belittle whomever he goes up against. He is a great debater, and a total prat, total ass. He seems to bitch about everything, belittles everything and everyone, stands for nothing never sees the good in anything. Take him away from the sycophants that he seem to surround himself with, that laud praise upon his humble head and you'll find a lonely scared little educated idiot muppet worried about where his next "fix" of applause and adulation is going to come from. He is not worthy to wipe Hitchens shoes.
Jack F (8 дней назад)
I don't believe in most of what the ABC has to say, may we please get rid of their words? I'm confused Mr. D https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yMOxBj0KRcY
Rose White (8 дней назад)
Have a look at this and especially from 4:00 and just ask yourself: what fool thinks himself evolved from this big gorilla! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IEYrIOWfwRw
viktor1496 (8 дней назад)
1)We did not evolve from gorilla's, they are distant cousins with whom we share a common ancestor. Just like how a house cat and a lynx are very different jet similar. 2)If we did not evolve from a common ancestor, how in the world do we share around 99.8% of our DNA with some chimp species? these DNA sequences are vast and VERY unique to each species, so why are they almost identical? Random chance? 3)We have a full fossil record of our ancestors all the way back to where we were more ape than modern man. Hard evidence that we evolved from an ape like species
ESKETITnBUTTER Yeet (8 дней назад)
I respect you too much to respect your ridiculous beliefs
Canadaboy9966 (8 дней назад)
Thank goodness for people like Mr. Dawkins and Christopher Hitchens (RIP). The world need more people like them. Don't be afraid to stand up and call out religion. It's 2019 now, let's leave these archaic and barbaric beliefs behind and move forward as human beings.
DONALD DUKE (9 дней назад)
Steve Fielding is such a wishy washy pussy he would fit right in with the United States Congress. How fucking stupid are Aussies to vote for this idiot? As stupid as Americans, that's how stupid ! !
Christina Carlsson (9 дней назад)
So Ayers Rock does not exist then...because it´s about 600 million years old according to scientists and geologists...
Niki Phan (9 дней назад)
Excellent Dawkins!
Alex Lagas (9 дней назад)
Being a politician is one of those jobs you don't need a certificate for, this is why any political group consists of complete idiots 99% of them.
Brad Gaines (10 дней назад)
I wish I could be around 100 years from now when people look back and laugh at these religious idiots.
Impostor82 (10 дней назад)
Tony Burke.... what a moron
Marina Proger (10 дней назад)
Ignorance is universal I see..
Bret Zajac (10 дней назад)
Dawkins is such an amature on religion. He cannot even tell the difference between Catholic religion and Christianity. Complete fraud.
Bret Zajac (3 дня назад)
+viktor1496 moron look at the proof. Jesus rose from the dead witnessed by 500 people and split time in two AD/BC. again moron formal writing is only 5000 years old and the bible speaks of pre-mankind and pre-universe, you cant get much older than that. God does not call everyone vik he just is not calling you and thats fine.
viktor1496 (3 дня назад)
+Bret Zajac Ah yes, sure. You realise Hinduism and Buddhism are older than even Judaism right? When it comes to world religion, the Jews and especially the Christians and Muslims are quite the newcomers. So what with those who lived before even Judaism existed? Point is, you are arrogant beyond believe to think your specific version of a specific god is the true one. Especially when so many and older ones exist
Bret Zajac (3 дня назад)
+viktor1496 and Jesus said the road to life is narrow and very few take it. So i guess he was right again. Its not a matter of numbers its a matter of truth.
viktor1496 (3 дня назад)
+Bret Zajac Ok so i was right, you do believe that catholics are following pagan doctrine. So let's see, catholics are roughly HALF of all christians worldwide. That leaves us with a maximum of 16% of the world that follows your thinking. Take out the people that follow the scientific stance (most of western europe for example) and that leaves you with a MAX of 7% of the people that walk this earth . 7 PERCENT, why don't you sit and think about that for a change?
Bret Zajac (4 дня назад)
+viktor1496 trinity also pagan established 325 years after Jesus.
kream (10 дней назад)
The moralities from the bible that were mentioned are from the book of Leviticus and only explain the state laws at that time. The true absolute moralities of the bible are within the 10 commandments which everyone would agree are reasonable and pure rules to live by.
Sopho Nax (6 дней назад)
2/10 commendments are reasonable (but only if we understand "kill" as "murder" and "steal" as "stealing out of greed" - I wouldn't condemn killing a person out of self-defense and I wouldn't condemn a starving person who steals food to survive). The other 8 are definitely not reasonable, as the comment above pointed out pretty well.
zivkovicable (9 дней назад)
The only commandments worth following are the universal rules that are found in every religion & followed by non believers too. Don't steal. don't kill. don't be dick. The first five biblical Commandments are self serving, all about praising only one God & him being jealous.  Then we get to honouring father & mother. Now that should depend on what they are like. What if dad is a rapist?  Then there is no killing - fair enough, but hardly original. The Buddhists & Hindus say the same, & they've were around for longer. Adultery - sex outside marriage. Don't see much wrong with that as long as it's consenting & doesn't involve cheating.. Certainly not worth the death penalty by stoning as mandated in the Bible. Stealing - same as killing, a universal rule that didn't start with the ten commandments.  Thou shall not bear false witness - Lying is mostly wrong, but i can think of occasions where could be necessary & the most moral thing to do. Then the last one - Coveting. The whole of human progress is based on this. Someone sees a neighbour has invented the wheel, they want one too. if we didn't covet we'd be living in caves. I bet you coveted those cool shades & headphones you are wearing. Then there is the stuff the Bible misses out. It is ok to own another human in slavery. It's fine to treat women as second class citizens who must keep quiet.
Hm Grraarrpffrzz (10 дней назад)
You mean "don't support slavery, don't rape"? Oh wait, the Bible condones those... How moral.
Sahasranshu 143 (10 дней назад)
What is a sjw??
Sam Monroe (10 дней назад)
KIXK IT
Mike (11 дней назад)
Meanwhile slavery still exists today in some Muslim countries.
Paulo Forged (11 дней назад)
I'm a Christian and I believe Christ was a wave of love in one man that tried his best to help us out of the greed and hate we still have today, I feel God is the energy behind all creation and some use source in a bad way because they wish to stay here repeatedly and enjoy the dirty aspect of animistic humanity (Satanism) Many love Christ and the will he had to stand up for what he knew we could do together, we can make this planet shine like Tesla (A Christ) said before he was ruined by the greed of others. We do now have an opportunity to be a Christ civilization again and I just hope we all can see that we evolved within God's universe from whatever we started at and I also feel that God evolves along with us without knowing what is going to be created God conscious being might see what is coming but might choose not to mostly and leaves us be without the need for itself to always be sad. I feel that aliens are part of creation, why would God stop at anywhere at all? I love God for all of this and science is getting closer to the raw energy of all light source and we are to evolve again right now and a lot of people on Earth already are Christ. We need a fair few this time round there wasn't as many of us last time round.
Paulo Forged (10 дней назад)
+Hm Grraarrpffrzz I am not in belief of those books, who says God did anything of the sort? I am well aware that ALL books are written but who is the dictator? Could the God most worship be the Satan God of the Earth only and this God makes all other gods and is kind of misleading mankind knowing that we are greedy gits and love death? I follow what I wish to and my God is the energy that precedes all and is just there as whatever I want it to be, the love I am is the God I love and the love of most men is the bankers we are. Science is intellectual brilliance of course yet something put it all somewhere and no matter how many there are in between there will always be one before :)
Hm Grraarrpffrzz (10 дней назад)
+Paulo Forged So that's why God mauled children to death with bears he summoned and committed mass murder by drowning mankind because of the faults he gave it... And condoned slavery and rape because that's all "love"...
Paulo Forged (10 дней назад)
+Hm Grraarrpffrzz Ignorance thought it was bliss, Christ came to show us that our own sword was already cutting off our gonads and here we still are 2k years becoming Satanicals.
Hm Grraarrpffrzz (10 дней назад)
Oh yes, Christ was a wave of love. That's why he said _"Do not suppose that I have come to bring peace to the earth. I did not come to bring peace, but a sword."_
ken (11 дней назад)
can't form a counter arguement so they start crying "no respect"
Dawn Broker (11 дней назад)
Stupid grown up adults except Richard Dawkins, of course.
Benchomp (12 дней назад)
Lol at Julie Bishop, if there is a god, she won't be meeting him. She will be burning in the fires of hell for her actions on earth. Luckily for her, it isn't real.
Chris and Liz Sizemore (12 дней назад)
While I don't believe in creationism per se, based on these clips edited together the audience was full of a-holes. Laughing at those who hold an opinion different from yours is absolutely horrid behavior, especially under the social setting of a 'debate'. I don't care who you are or what you believe to be true. That was just flat out disgusting and disrespectful.
Silvas Are Nuts (12 дней назад)
Time has come for everyone to have knowledge and study in Science to understand and comprehend scientific theory to argue upon than to display their ignorance in the public!
watchman48 (12 дней назад)
Neither Dawkins nor scientists are infallible... Dawkins believe himself to be much smarter than ever one else but the Bible clearly reveals that the fool will most always think the same thing as what Dawkins does...  Scientists were claiming that we were entering a new ice age in the late 1950s... There was no ice age...if this Dawkins is totally honest and truthful with him self and others, he would have to have the knowledge of all of man's past history to this present day; in essence, he himself would have to be a god, knowing all that there is to be known.   So, Mr. Dawkins, have read the Bible through in your search for God?   If not why should God reveal Himself to someone who is not interested enough to search for the truth? The Bible tells us that the fool says, there is no God.   The most likely reason the fool would say this, is because he has never made an honest and truthful search for God..  Lee Strobel did a two year search to prove the non-existence of God, you sir should read the proof of his findings in "The Case For Faith" and "The Case For Christ."  Many will claim that science has disproved the existence of God... That is a lie..   Here is just a tiny bit of my own proof and evidence of God existence... Google: "Watchman On The Wall - The Greater Message."  There is no way in the world that I could have known these facts which I had written about but that they came from God the Holy Spirit... If one would say the things I said about the Holy Spirit and it be a lie the Bible says that would be blasphemy against the Holy Spirit from whence there is no forgiveness..  I could tell you of many dreams, visions that have saved lives, more spoken messages in my left ear and even spoken messages to others all of which came true just as they were spoken and all of which were in line with God's Truth. Jesus' birth, life, death and resurrection was the fulfillment of 330 prophecies which were written in the Old Testament any where from 500 years or so to as much as 2,000 or so before His birth... You claim to be a man of science than here is a link for finding verse which were written hundreds of years before modern day scientists proved these facts...  Scientific Facts In The Bible - InPlainsite.org
Hm Grraarrpffrzz (9 дней назад)
​+watchman48 _"Why do you believe the lies of those that have said the Bible copied a lot of texts from the older Epic of Gilgamesh."_ We know that the Epic of Gilgamesh exists. We know that it is older than the Bible. We see texts in the Bible that are very very close to those in the Epic. So close, that writing the same text by coincidence is near impossible. So they copied it. What reason do you have to believe that this is a lie?
watchman48 (9 дней назад)
Why do you believe the lies of those that have said the Bible copied a lot of texts from the older Epic of Gilgamesh...  Because in your mind you don't want to believe the truth...  I'm sorry but I have spent more than enough time with you, I must go to others that might be truly interested in the truth...
Hm Grraarrpffrzz (9 дней назад)
​+watchman48 _"You don't accept the proof that I speak about because your mind is closed off to the truth"_ A story in a book is no proof. _"God use many metaphors or analogies in the Bible"_ Which is nothing else but taking something from the Bible, and saying _"Yeah that is written there, but what is _*_meant_*_ is what I say"_ which means that the Bible says anything you want it to. Maybe "God" is a metaphor for the human will, and not meant as a personal deity? "God is omnipotent" = "The human will is omnipotent". How do you know what is meant literally and what is not? It's just a matter of personal interpretation, which means that nothing in the Bible can be considered to be the absolute truth. _"It can takes a life of reading and studying the Bible to understand these things... "_ So if the Buddhists say that it requires a lifetime of reading and studying to understand Buddhism... And the Muslims say that about Islam, and the Hindus about Hinduism, and Christians about Christianity... How do you choose which one to spend your life on? You see the problem? _"I am truly sorry that I am not smart enough to convince you..."_ Maybe it has nothing to do with you being smart or not smart. Maybe I am right, and there is no God? All tenthousands of deities are invisible, including yours. All religious people say that their deity is true and all others are not. Thousands of years ago, Christians said that "the end is near", and thousands of years later, there is no end in sight. The Bible copied a lot of texts from the older Epic of Gilgamesh. So how can it be the truth if it copied stuff from other religions? A lot of things in the Bible we know is incorrect. If I look around, then the world makes perfect sense without a deity. With a deity, lots of things make no sense anymore.
watchman48 (9 дней назад)
You don't accept the proof that I speak about because your mind is closed off to the truth, just as Pilate's mind was closed when he asked Jesus, "What is truth?"   God use many metaphors or analogies in the Bible which are comparisons made between two or more things using figurative or descriptive language. Metaphors serve to make difficult to understand ideas or concepts more tangible.  Metaphors also infuse written text with vivid descriptions that make the text more vibrant and enjoyable to read. Proverbs 13:14 - The teaching of the wise is a fountain of life.  Teaching is compared to a fountain, but not just any fountain. The fountain of life is a common metaphor that suggests a continuing source of sustenance and life. Isaiah 64:8 - But now, O Lord, You are our Father, We are the clay, and You our potter; And all of us are the work of Your hand.  God is compared to a potter who molds clay. God’s followers are the clay and are subject to his design and influence. Psalms 23:1 - The Lord is my shepherd, I shall not want.  God is compared to a shepherd, someone whose duty it is to look after and care for his sheep. John 6:35  -  Jesus said to them, ‘I am the bread of life; he who comes to me will not hunger, and he who believes in me will never thirst.’  Jesus compares himself to bread. The bread of life is a symbolic idea that Jesus offers eternal fulfillment. Like bread sustains us in life, Jesus’s metaphor suggests that he can sustain his followers in a spiritual sense. Revelations 19:7 -  Let us rejoice and be glad and give the glory to Him, for the marriage of the Lamb has come and His bride has made herself ready.   The lamb is Jesus, the bride is the Church, or the followers of Christ, and the marriage is the union of the two in heaven. It can takes a life of reading and studying the Bible to understand these things...  And there are many, many more that I could show you but your mind is closed to accepting or understanding these things just as it is with my evidence I have given you for the existence of God... I am truly sorry that I am not smart enough to convince you... I just barely graduated from high school over 51 years ago and my writing and sentence structure, and punctuation should certainly be the proof this statement... Why do you think I have spent so much time with you, it is the love of Christ within me... God wishes that none should perish but all to come to Christ but He will not force anyone to believe in Him...  As a watchman I am required to share what I know with all who will listen... If I would reject the opportunity to share God's warnings than God would hold me accountable for the blood of those that I rejected to warn.  Minister or Pastors are held at a much higher degree of accountability.  Even the typical believer will be help accountable at a lesser degree for not sharing what they know of Christ.
Hm Grraarrpffrzz (9 дней назад)
+watchman48 _"The Earth resting on pillars most likely refers to the foundations, or the continental plates which do shake"_ So in other words: nothing in the bible is meant as it was written, anything is up for interpretation and can mean anything you can read into it.
Gabon Sansworth (12 дней назад)
I can understand Dawkins not believing in religion, but why is he so filled with such intense hate and anger?
Dankstar Memes (12 дней назад)
Gabon Sansworth Religion deserves to be ridiculed and exterminated, doesn’t matter if it’s Islam, Christianity, or the phantom up my ass. It is a burden in the 21st century society where evolution disproved the cult of religion and free will hundreds of years ago. If you believe Bronze Age myths from sheep herders hold any significant precedent than you are surely purged with delusion.
debasish naiding (12 дней назад)
these guys need sadhguru
Gustave Ruahe (12 дней назад)
in high level of math we say: "logic is not really logic as you might think is logic and even thinking like that might not as well be logic in a sens because..." . To be simple, everytime we think that we are done with a study are whatever; we find ourself with more question because there are other problems to solve which is not logic but true. Look at Quamtum physics for exemple, they found out about the atoms and then that which defy everything they could imagine to be logic. Science is not about discovering; it is about witnessing at new level. (oh that work like that! ah ok cool. what about that then?) "The Perception" might not be what you think it is. In resumé: Logic is for losers, because they won't push themselves.
Stacey E (13 дней назад)
Ridicule is the only weapon to use against ridiculous propositions.
Mad Lad (13 дней назад)
Well im not a Faithfull Person but not seeing the great Metapher which ist Jesus is rather stupid in itself.
Hm Grraarrpffrzz (10 дней назад)
It's less a metaphor and more proof how paradoxical religion is.
Kourosh Cyrus (13 дней назад)
From Iran: Islam is full of shit. Islam destroyed Iran. Fuck Islam and Allah and Mohammad
Karl Björn (10 дней назад)
indeed
Michael (13 дней назад)
Richard Dawkins has great patience talking to imbeciles
Michael (13 дней назад)
We are proof of evolution. Creation implies an end yet we are constantly creating, and developing and which is evolution. The point he is getting at is that we are made in the image of God, therefore if God can come out of thin air, so can we. If we can be created, so can God. But this would contradict the very nature of God. God made us in his image, but we are not perfect, that means God is not perfect either. But again this would contradict the very nature of God.
Jason L (13 дней назад)
Has Dawkins ever debated an Islamic scholar?
Dankstar Memes (12 дней назад)
Jason L yes he has.
Souradeep Bhattacharya (13 дней назад)
I genuinely feel bad for Dr.Dawkins, what a humble,intelligent & well spoken person surrounded by super ignorant adults who might one day worship Harry potter.
mark Jones (13 дней назад)
When I was a teenager myself along with other witnesses saw two UFOs close up in a field,take off&fly up a mountain side!when I explained this to my baptist preacher,he fell about laughing! I just looked at him stupidly and said oh!you think I'm lying?? And everyone else is lying too??he just ushered me away wiping tears from his eyes!weirdly,years later,I worked for a man who was top of his church in the Jehovah's witness community! We where talking about religion, and I told him what had happened. Then he said something that really threw me!when I said-so,do you believe in UFO's?? He said-yes!!I'm like-wha!!??he went on,yes,I do,because I,v seen them on various occasions around the farm!(I worked from his remote bleak farm)so I was expecting him to say they where angels or something but no he said I don't know what they are,an neither do you!!good point well made I thought!
nuff sed (13 дней назад)
If a priest was posed/positioned as DAWKINS is at 3:36 then i would check there wasn't a you choir boy below the desk.
Henk Lubbe (13 дней назад)
I believe moralities comes from God. I also believe that the lens of an eye cannot come into existence through evolution. I challenge everyone and anyone to prove that moralities comes from another source. Alternatively, I challenge everyone to prove to me that the lens of an eye came into existence through evolution.
Noah Smith (13 дней назад)
Fuck you. How dare you even suggest that my moral thinking comes from some invisible cunt in the sky and not from my own mind and upbringing? Also, all you need to understand how evolution works is a high school education and a double digit IQ, you dense cunt.
Arpan Samuel (14 дней назад)
Santa Claus doesn't exist subscribe
Eileen D (14 дней назад)
Richard Dawkins wakes up irritated
friend2truth (14 дней назад)
Bunch of fucking wankers on that panel with Richard.
Dan Chan (13 дней назад)
Dawkins is a loser
Jonathan Moose (14 дней назад)
Wow. a few people here just love to run around questions
37Dionysos (14 дней назад)
"I'm not an expert, but I know what everybody should believe!" Fuckin' twat.
Ram Jam (15 дней назад)
at least Islam understands science.
Hm Grraarrpffrzz (10 дней назад)
You mean the part where the prophet flew on a horse to the Moon and split it? How does that work scientifically?
clement boutaric (15 дней назад)
Richard Dawkins doesn't always ask good question. The one at 4:07 isn't needed, because the woman just said that you don't have to believe each words written on the new testament. You can see the whole thing as a giant philosophical novel, giving enough advice to build an entire lifestyle. Edit : But his last answer is brilliant.

Хотите оставить комментарий?

Присоединитесь к YouTube, или войдите, если вы уже зарегистрированы.